Pakistani accusations against a French citizen & penal codes allegedly applicable

According to the Pakistani social media user Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Aalam, tweeting under @GruaAbuseArkive and @BetterInventory, the French citizen, Bernard Grua, would be responsible, in Pakistan, for assault on & harassment of victims of a rapist-pedophile, for reaching out to a remote community in order to repress evidence, and for forcing Pakistanis to submit evidence to him instead of to law. We will place these accusations into their context, confront them with the reality and try to understand their motivation.
According to the Pakistani social media user Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Aalam, tweeting under @GruaAbuseArkive and @BetterInventory, the French citizen, Bernard Grua, would be responsible, in Pakistan, for assault on & harassment of victims of a rapist-pedophile, for reaching out to a remote community in order to repress evidence, and for forcing Pakistanis to submit evidence to him instead of to law. We will place these accusations into their context, confront them with the reality and try to understand their motivation.

En français.

Content

Case presentation by Ramla Akhtar

@BetterInventory, previously @BestInventoryPR is an impersonating twitter account created by Ramla Akhtar who also tweets under @GruaAbuseArkive

The laws mentioned on this tweet are already presented in the following paper:

Detailed text of the “penal codes” mentioned by Ramla Akhtar

We will, here, analyse the accusations of Ms Ramla Akhtar’s, a Pakistani social media user, against “Bernard G*”, i.e. myself, Bernard Grua, a French citizen.

These are the penal codes applicable to French citizen Mr. Bernard G* for his assault on & harassment of victims of a rapist-pedophile, and for reaching out to a remote community in order to repress evidence, and for forcing Pakistanis to submit evidence to him instead of to law.

Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Aalam, @GruaAbuseArkive on her impersonating Twitter account @BetterInventory, August 20, 2021.

Back to table of content

Substantiation of Ramla Akhtar’s accusations against Bernard Grua

a) RA: Assault & harassment

My Twitter account is @BernardGrua. I live in Nantes, France. My job is to provide inventory services under my small individual firm, Best Inventory France, @BestInventory on Twitter. I am also a photographer and a contributor to French and foreign media. I was once in Pakistan, three years ago.

I don’t harass anybody. But I have to defend my reputation challenged by Ms Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Aalam, the Karachi woman who stalks me with her @GruaAbuseArkive and @BetterInventory Twitter impersonating accounts since more than two years. I never met with Ms Ramla Akhtar and, except with her, I don’t argue with anybody privately or publicly on social media.

Ramla Akhtar Twitter picture profile on @GruaAbuseArkive
Ramla Akhtar, Twitter picture profile on @GruaAbuseArkive
Ramla Akhtar, capture of a publc video posted on one of her Facebook pages, "Ramla Aalam", August 20 , 2021
Ramla Akhtar, capture of a publc video posted on one of her Facebook pages, “Ramla Aalam”, August 20 , 2021

On June 5, 2019, I proposed conciliation to Ms Ramla Akhtar. She rejected it, presented it as a threat and enhanced the conflict. On February 9, 2020, I sent a Formal Demand Notice to this person. She, again, rejected it and introduced it, thanks to selected quotes, as a threat. On July 20, 2021, I sent a last Formal Demand Notice, which faced the same fate than the previous one.

As of July 18, 2021, Pakistani Ramal Akhtar sent 1,757 tweets against me.

Left column number of tweets sent against Bernard Grua as of July 18, 2021, by Ramla Akhtar

One of Ms Ramla Akhtar’s method is calumnious denunciation. The authorities of my city, Nantes, are their first target.

Main addressees of @GruaAbuseArkive calumnious denunciations against Bernard GruaNumber of tweets as of July 18, 2021
@NantesMetropole (Nantes area administration)130
@Johanna_Rolland (Nantes Mayor)111
@FranceInPak (French embassy in Islamabad)84
@PoliceNationale (French police)71
@PoliceNat44 (Nantes police)49
@NantesFr (Nantes municipality)30
@PakInFrance (French embassy in Islamabad)16
Main addressees of Ms Ramla Akhtar’s calumnious denunciation as of July 18, 2021

Tweets shared against me, Bernard Grua, are loaded with hashtags and keywords in order to promote hatred and violence. In Pakistan, numerous allegations could lead to death penalty or slaughtering, thanks to the law of Lynch.

Main defamatory hate speech & calumnious denunciation key words of @GruaAbuseArkiveAll tweetsTweets targeting Bernard Grua as of July 18, 2021
Pedo/pedophile548387
Abuse/abuser/abusing649366
Threat464298
Troll/trollism382251
Rape/rapist526215
Crime/criminal411203
Stalker/stalking183147
Terror/terrorism258113
White37590
Harassment/harassing18981
Fascist/fascism7936
Blackmail5936
Racist/racism10030
Murder/murderer12528
Torture6126
Supremacist/supremacism6924
Nazi/nazism5817
Colonial/colonialist9615
May keywords used by Ms amla Akhtar as of July 18, 2021

To promote her stalking, Ms Ramla Akhtar surfs on the emotion created by the numerous blood crimes perpetrated in Pakistan. She always connects myself with these horrors. Since Noor Mukadam and Adiba of Shimshal murders, the new hashtag she uses with my name is “feminicide”. It is presented in such a way that I would be responsible for these assassinations and that Ms Ramla Akhtar, because of me, would suffer the same martyr’s fate than the ladies sacrificed to Pakistani patriarchy. Once a cause is not in the mood anymore, Ms Ramla Akhtar dumps it as she did for #Metoo, #BLM (Black Lives Matter), #POC (People Of Colour), the motorway rape case, child condition, Jeffrey Epstein‘s case, etc. In this speech, we can often find an Islamized version of QAnon, an ideology of the American far right.

Even Afghanistan is in Ramla Akhtar’s scope

Best Inventory, Bernard Grua’s company has terrorist activities in Afghanistan according to Ramla Akhtar.
“FEMINICIDE” on one of the regularly changing profiles of Best Inventory impersonating Twitter account.
PATRIARCHY, PEDO ALLY on one of the regularly changing profiles of @GruaAbuseArkive Twitter account impersonating Bernard Grua last name in its ID and mentioning his first name in bio.

Back to table of content

b) RA: Victims of a rapist-pedophile

I don’t know any victim of a rapist-pedophile. I do confirm Ms Ramla Akhtar was not the rape victim, as she pretends she was, during her childhood or later. In May/June 2019, during one week Ms Akhtar spammed by messenger box. In a hope tostop this harassment, I did not answer. It is available here: Hunza: interviews with an outsider-troll. Eventually, she gave important information.

Ms Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Alam, @GruaAbuseArkive, wrote me she had her first sexual experience at the age of 33.

Ms Ramla Akhtar, aka Rmala Alam, @GruaAbuseArkive, wrote me she was not raped by the tourist guide of northern Pakistan she frequently mentions. She decided by herself to flirt with this man. And she had sex with him. She more or less lived with him in Sost, Pakistan. She got pregnant and got an unwanted baby, Sofia.

The man with whom Ms Ramla Akhtar had sex was already married. Adultery is punished by law in Pakistan. Moreover Pakistan is the country with the highest percentage (89%), in the world, of people demanding stoning for adultery.

To avoid troubles, Ms Ramla Akhtar and her sexual partner concluded a “paper wedding” in Islamabad. She became, “officially”, the second wife of a man she pretends, now, being a rapist-pedophile.

Ms Ramla Akhtar, based on a private conversation dating back November 2012 that she stole from the phone of her “husband”, asserts having an evidence of rape between her partner/husband and one of his nieces. This is nothing more than joking (with, actually, bad taste) about a virtual kiss. A very oriented interpretation of this stolen conversation could consider it was harassment. In no way, including in puritan Pakistan, it could be considered as a rape.

The above conversation is the only “evidence” Ms Ramla Akhtar can produce to support her thousands of tweets. Although it is a private stolen conversation Ms Ramla Akhtar frequently posts it on Facebook and Twitter, in violation with these media policies.

To summarize, I don’t know victims. I am aware of just one “potential victim”, Ms Akhtar, who was not able for more than two years to document her alleged status and who, in the opposite, gave all indications for considering she was sharing false information for revenge purposes.

Back to table of content

c) RA: Reaching out to a remote community in order to repress evidence

Reaching out to a remote community...

One year before I heard from Ms Ramla Akhtar, I was in Lahore, in Islamabad and in Hunza, including Gojal and its remote valley of Chapursan. I wrote numerous articles in English and in French about this region. They were published on my blogs, on a French media, Agoravox, on Medium and on Pakistani media such as Passu Times and Pamir Times. See for example: High Asia, stories of the Karakoram. These papers are very popular in Pakistan. They are complimented and shared. They never faced any contradiction, including when they talk from Islam.

High Asia, stories of the Karakoram

I also made numerous pictures of local people that I published, always after I got the agreement of the people shown on them, or after the authorization of a responsible adult if they were kids.

Petites filles wakhies sur le seuil de la maison familiale,  Zoodkhun village de la vallée de Chapursan  07/08/2018 © Bernard Grua
Wakhi people slideshow
Les cônes et le village de Passu, le long de la rivière Hunza et de la Karakoram Highway en cours d'après-midi © Bernard Grua
Upper Hunza, Gojal slideshow
Le Rush peak, 5,098 m, , vue matinale à partir de Duikar (Eagle's Nest) © Bernard Grua
Medium Hunza slideshow
10-DSC_5007NB © Bernard Grua
Karakoram slideshow

As consequences, I got hundreds of friend requests on Facebook from Pakistan. I did not ask for. They just reached me spontaneously. I am still in contact with some of them. They helped me to write about Wakhi culture, music and religion. I submitted them my papers for their review before publication, to make sure they were accurate.

During the Covid lockdown and to help the family of the Chapursan guesthouse I made two websites as gifts: Pamir Serai and Pamir Trails. Because people trust me, I was alerted by one Reshit villager, I met one year before in Passu, about the Facebook public allegations of Ms Ramla Akhtar against the whole Chapursan community and against its foreign guests.

I am not accountable to a Karachi woman, who I never met with, about my relations with people from Pakistan mountains. Unless considering north Pakistan is under the colonialist rule of Ms Ramla Akhtar, she has no right to decide with whom I could talk in Hunza. She has no right either to with whom a north Pakistan minority group could interact domestically or internationally. It looks strange that I have to explain this. However, this presentation is intended to clarify the background of Ms Ramla Akhtar, who considers negatively the Wakhi ethnic and religious minority and who is hostile to its western visitors.

Hate speech against mountainers and call for violence on Ms Ramla Akhtar Facebook blog page
Ms Ramla Akhtar wants north Pakistan being cleansed from white visitors (foreign travelers) for replacing them with POC (People Of Color), the brown skin population of southern Pakistan

…to repress evidence

Since May 2019, the beginning of Ms Ramla Akhtar’s campaign, I have never seen or even heard about any evidences shared by Ms Ahtar. I also noted that, despite repeated statements of an imminent seizure of justice, she never started any action in that direction. Such a retention of her “evidences” raises questions.

Back to table of content

d) RA: To submit evidence to him instead of to law

I, indeed, asked some of my local close contacts about evidences of Ramla Akhtar’s allegations in order to get a fair view of her case. Actually most of the testimonies I received were spontaneously posted under my report. Although they are detailed and factual, I don’t know who wrote them. Ms Ramla Akhtar was displeased with these testimonies. This may explain part of her anger against myself.

Testimonies spontaneously received about Ms Ramla Akhtar’s child maltreatment

I always considered law should be involved in this case. I recommended the French embassy and Pakistan authorities to have an interview with Ms Ramla Akhtar. The French embassy in Islamabad told three times (once by phone and twice on Twitter) to Ms Akhtar she should contact her local police authorities. She did not. Instead continued to spam the French embassy with calumnious denunciations.

I did not obstruct justice, on the opposite, I formally sent Ms Ramla Akhtar’s allegations of abuses to Pakistan embassy in Paris, to France embassy in Islamabad, to Gilgit Pakistan government, to Nantes (my city) municipality, to Lahore Police, to Islamabad police, to Pakistan Federal Investigation Agency cybercrime wing and to the prosecutor of nantes High Court. I have, moreover, posted on line the “evidences” of Mrs. Ramla Akhtar here, there and again there. They are accessible to everyone.

See:

Back to table of content

Conclusion

Let’s conclude that sharing unsupported allegations, defamation, lies, hate speech, calumnious denunciation, racism and xenophobia is called cyberstalking.
Report to PTA unlawful content on social media
This is not “justice” or “law” as erroneously said by Ms Ramla Akhtar. Cyberstalking is a crime under the Pakistani Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act of 2016. It must be reported to PTA. I did my part.
Report about Ms Ramla Akhtar’s hate speech on social media to Pakistani Federal Investigation Agency for cyber-crimes v

Ramla Akhtar: complaint to Pakistani Federal Investigation Agency for cyber-crimes

Read also:

Back to table of content

Chapursan Valley by Bernard Grua, 2018
Zood Khun (Chapursan Valley) water mill by Bernard Grua, 2018

Published by Bernard Grua

Graduated from Paris "Institut d'Etudes Politiques", financial auditor, photographer, founder and spokesperson of the worldwide movement which opposed to the delivery of Mitral invasion vessels to Putin's Russia, contributor to French and foreign media for culture, heritage and geopolitics.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create your website with WordPress.com
Get started
%d bloggers like this: